Key takeaways
- For most kitchens, a Cuisinart CPT-160P1 two-slice or CPT-180P1 four-slice is the practical pick under $150, the Breville "A Bit More" (BTA720 two-slice…
For most kitchens, a Cuisinart CPT-160P1 two-slice or CPT-180P1 four-slice is the practical pick under $150, the Breville “A Bit More” (BTA720 two-slice, BTA730 long-slot four-slice) suits people who want smarter toasting controls, and the KitchenAid KMT2115 or Smeg TSF01 fit buyers who care about looks and wider slots. A toaster is one of the cheapest appliances to get right, so this guide focuses on slot width, capacity, controls and cleaning, using what the makers list.
The budget cap here is generous for a toaster, which means you can ignore the cheapest units and choose by features: slot width for bagels and thick bread, independent controls on four-slice models, and a crumb tray you can actually remove. Below are the current models worth knowing, how they differ, and which listings to skip.
Our top picks
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
At a glance: toasters to consider
| Model | Best for | Key stated specs | Limits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cuisinart 2-Slice Classic Stainless (CPT-160P1) | Reliable everyday toasting | 1.5-inch wide slots; six-setting browning dial; reheat, defrost and bagel buttons; extra-lift lever; slide-out crumb tray; cord wrap; about 10.75 by 7.13 by 7.13 inches; 3-year warranty | Two slices only |
| Cuisinart 4-Slice Classic Stainless (CPT-180P1) | Families, mixed breads | Dual control panels, each with a six-setting dial plus reheat, defrost and bagel; 1.5-inch slots; extra-lift lever; about 10.65 by 11.15 by 7.5 inches | Larger counter footprint; weight figures differ between pages |
| Breville “A Bit More” 2-slice (BTA720) | Bagels, thick bread, fruit bread | Extra-wide, deep slots; LED toasting progress; one-touch A Bit More, Lift and Look, Bagel and Frozen functions; brushed stainless; about 8.2 by 11.3 by 7.3 inches | More controls to learn |
| Breville “A Bit More” 4-slice long-slot (BTA730) | Long slices, artisan loaves | Same function set in a long-slot format; about 8.1 by 16.1 by 7.6 inches | Wide; takes counter length |
| KitchenAid 2-slice with manual lift lever (KMT2115) | Style plus wide slots | 900 W; slots take items up to 1 1/8 inch thick; five shade settings; bagel, cancel and completion alert; no defrost; hand-wash crumb tray | No defrost function |
| KitchenAid 4-slice (KMT4115) | Four slices with independent controls | wattage listed differently across sources; dual independent controls on the four-slice only | Listings differ on details, so check the maker’s product guide |
| Smeg 2-slice (TSF01) | Design-led kitchens | 980 W; six browning settings; reheat, defrost and bagel; 1.4-inch slot; 39-inch cord; about 12.2 by 7.7 by 7.75 inches | Positioned in a premium tier; may exceed this cap depending on color and listing |
How to choose a toaster
Slot width and depth
This is the spec that decides whether a toaster is frustrating or pleasant. The Cuisinart CPT-160P1 and CPT-180P1 list 1.5-inch slots. KitchenAid lists slots that take bread, bagels and English muffins up to 1 1/8 inch thick, and the Smeg TSF01 lists a 1.4-inch slot. Breville describes extra wide and deep slots on the BTA720 without a measurement in listings. If you buy thick sourdough or bagels, favor the wider listing, and remember that slot width differs from the thickness a toaster actually handles when the lever lowers the slice.
Capacity and independent controls
A four-slice toaster with dual controls works as two toasters in one, which is useful when one person wants a light shade and another a dark one. Cuisinart’s CPT-180P1 has two control panels, each with its own browning dial and function buttons. KitchenAid says dual independent controls are only on its four-slice model. If you cook mostly for one or two people, a two-slice unit takes less space and heats quickly.
Function buttons that earn their place
Bagel, defrost and reheat are the standard three. Cuisinart lists all three on its classic models, with LED indicators. The Smeg lists reheat, defrost and bagel. KitchenAid’s KMT2115 lists bagel and a completion alert but no defrost, which matters if you toast frozen bread. Breville’s A Bit More adds a little extra time with one press, and its Lift and Look lever lets you check progress without cancelling the cycle. These are useful only if you will use them daily.
Browning settings and consistency
Five to seven settings is typical. More settings make it easier to dial in a favorite shade, but the first few uses usually need adjustment, since shade depends on bread type, moisture and starting temperature. Makers do not publish evenness data, so treat the claims as feature descriptions, not guarantees.
Crumb tray and cleaning
Every toaster here lists a removable crumb tray, but the cleaning rules differ. KitchenAid’s guide states its crumb tray is hand-wash only. Cuisinart lists a slide-out tray and a BPA-free construction. Empty the tray frequently, since crumbs left to accumulate are a nuisance and potentially a fire risk.
Footprint and storage
The Smeg and KitchenAid two-slice units are close in width at roughly 7.5 to 7.7 inches, and the Breville BTA720 lists about 8.2. Four-slice models range from about 11 to 16 inches wide. Cord wrap or concealed cord storage is listed on Cuisinart, Smeg and Breville models.
The picks in detail
Cuisinart CPT-160P1 and CPT-180P1: the safe default
The Classic Stainless line is the clearest answer for people who just want a dependable toaster with a standard feature set. Both models list 1.5-inch slots, six browning settings, reheat, defrost and bagel buttons, an extra-lift lever and a slide-out crumb tray. The maker lists a limited 3-year warranty. The older white-and-stainless CPT-180W, the CPT-340 compact four-slice and the original CPT-160 are listed as discontinued, so buy the P1 variants that remain current.
Breville A Bit More (BTA720 and BTA730): the feature-rich option
Breville’s one-touch A Bit More function adds a short burst of extra toasting time, which helps when bread is slightly under-toasted. The Lift and Look lever raises the carriage so you can see the toast without ending the cycle. The BTA720 is the two-slice version, the BTA730 is the long-slot four-slice, and both are listed in brushed stainless. The US models are rated for 110 to 120 V. The BTA820 Die-Cast Smart Toaster is a different, higher-tier product.
KitchenAid KMT2115: style with wide slots
KitchenAid lists the KMT2115 at 900 W with five shade settings and a manual lift lever, and slots for up to 1 1/8 inch thickness. It has no defrost, so it fits toast-from-fresh households better than those who freeze sliced bread. The KMT4115 is the four-slice sibling and the only one with dual independent controls; listings differ on its wattage and details, so check the maker’s guide.
Smeg TSF01: design first
Smeg’s two-slice model lists 980 W, six browning settings, reheat, defrost and bagel functions, a 1.4-inch slot, automatic pop-up and an integrated cord wrap. It is a retro-styled piece. Because Smeg usually sits in a premium tier, it may exceed this cap in some colors or listings, so weigh it as a style purchase.
Budget tiers
| Tier | What you get | Trade-off |
|---|---|---|
| Budget | Basic two-slice toasters from mainstream makers, including Hamilton Beach lines; several listed 2-slice models have shown as out of stock or no longer available | Fewer shade settings, thinner slots, shorter warranties |
| Mid-range | Cuisinart CPT-160P1 and CPT-180P1; KitchenAid KMT2115 | Plain styling, some missing functions |
| Upper end of this cap | Breville A Bit More; Smeg TSF01 where available under the cap | More money for features or style |
| Above the cap | Breville die-cast and smart toasters such as the BTA820 | Not covered here |
Pick X if…
| If you… | Pick |
|---|---|
| Want a dependable toaster, nothing fancy | Cuisinart CPT-160P1 |
| Cook for four and want two shades at once | Cuisinart CPT-180P1 |
| Eat thick bagels or fruit bread | Breville BTA720 |
| Toast long artisan slices | Breville BTA730 |
| Want a stylish two-slice with wide slots and no defrost needed | KitchenAid KMT2115 |
| Want a statement design piece | Smeg TSF01 |
Alternatives and cautions
- Toaster oven instead: if you want to toast and bake small dishes, a toaster oven covers both jobs but takes more room.
- Hamilton Beach: several older two-slice and extra-wide Hamilton Beach models have shown as unavailable on listings, so they are left out of the picks; look for a currently listed Hamilton Beach model if you prefer the brand.
- Discontinued Cuisinart units: the CPT-340 and original CPT-160 are marked discontinued by the maker.
Safety and care
Never put a metal utensil, fork or knife into a toaster slot, even if it is switched off, unless the maker’s manual says otherwise; unplug it first if you must remove stuck food, and use a non-metal tool. Keep the toaster away from the edge of the counter, from water and from curtains or paper towels. Do not use it as a heater and do not leave it running unattended. Empty the crumb tray regularly and let the appliance cool before wiping. If a toaster smokes, trips a breaker or has a damaged cord, stop using it and contact the maker.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are four-slice toasters worth it?
They are worth it if you often toast for three or four people. Models with dual controls, such as the Cuisinart CPT-180P1, let two people choose different shades at once. If you toast for one or two, a two-slice unit is smaller and easier to store.
Do I need a defrost setting?
Only if you toast frozen bread. Cuisinart and Smeg list a defrost button; the KitchenAid KMT2115 does not. Without a defrost function, toasting frozen bread on a higher shade setting is a common workaround, but follow the manual.
What is the benefit of wide slots?
Wide slots let thick slices, bagels and English muffins fit without being squeezed. KitchenAid lists up to 1 1/8 inch, Cuisinart lists 1.5-inch slots and Smeg lists 1.4 inches. Slot width alone does not guarantee even toasting.
How often should I clean the crumb tray?
Empty it regularly, ideally weekly or whenever you notice crumbs building up, with the toaster unplugged and cool. KitchenAid states its tray is hand-wash only. Built-up crumbs can burn and produce smoke.
Is it safe to free a stuck slice with a fork?
No. Unplug the toaster and let it cool, then remove the slice with a non-metal tool if the manual allows, or follow the manual’s guidance on clearing jams. Metal in a slot can touch the heating elements, which is why makers warn against it.
What does the A Bit More button do?
Breville describes it as a one-touch function that adds a short amount of extra toasting time to a cycle that is nearly done. It is a convenience for fine-tuning shade when the toast is slightly pale, and it works alongside the Lift and Look lever.
Related guides



