Key takeaways
- Under $150, the Hamilton Beach 25410 is the current pick for households that want a roomy press with a floating lid that also works as a small indoor…
Under $150, the Hamilton Beach 25410 is the current pick for households that want a roomy press with a floating lid that also works as a small indoor grill, while the Breville Panini Duo BSG520XL is the choice for sandwiches with a four-position adjustable top plate, if you can still find it new. Availability is the main caveat here: Breville’s Canadian page marks the Panini Duo as discontinued, and Hamilton Beach’s page for the older 25462Z marks it as no longer available, so both are described below as models that may only appear through remaining stock. Cuisinart’s well-known 5-in-1 Griddler line also appears in listings, but one maker page marks it as discontinued, so it is left out of the picks.
Our top picks
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
What matters in a panini press
A panini press browns and compresses a sandwich between two heated plates. The features that change results are plate size (how many sandwiches fit), a lid that floats or adjusts for thick bread, plates that are easy to clean, and heat that is strong enough to crisp bread without drying the filling. Most of these machines have no thermostat, only an on/off light, so food and timing do the work.
At a glance
| Model | Best for | Key stated specs | Limits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Breville Panini Duo BSG520XL | Thick sandwiches and consistent results | The maker’s US page lists 1500 W, 110-120 V, two-slice capacity, brushed stainless housing, aluminum plates with a non-stick coating, four height settings; about 12.6 x 14.1 x 3.7 in.; storage clip, rear foot for upright storage, cord wraps into the base | Two-slice capacity; the maker’s Canadian page for the non-XL BSG520 says discontinued, so availability varies by region and new stock may be limited; listings differ on warranty length |
| Hamilton Beach Panini Press 25462Z (previous model) | Budget family use, thick sandwiches, if still in stock | The maker lists 10 x 8 in. nonstick grids, floating lid, locking lid for open-face use, power and preheat lights, upright storage; about 4.53 x 12.6 x 12.3 in.; fits 2 to 3 sandwiches | The maker’s page marks it no longer available, so it may only be found as remaining stock; no drip tray; preheat time recommended (six minutes per the maker) |
| Hamilton Beach Panini Press and Indoor Grill 25410 | Sandwiches plus grilled vegetables and burgers | The maker lists a 95 sq in. nonstick surface, floating lid, dishwasher-safe drip tray for fat, power and preheat lights, scraper, lid locks for upright storage | Listed dimensions appear to be for upright storage or packaging; compare with your cabinet space |
Breville Panini Duo BSG520XL
Breville’s US page describes a 1500 W press with a brushed stainless housing and aluminum cooking plates that have a PFOA-free non-stick coating. Older retailer listings describe a ribbed top plate and a different coating, while current maker pages show flat plates, so listings differ. A flat top and bottom is good for sandwiches and quesadillas, but it will not leave grill marks.
The main feature is height control. Breville lists four settings that let the top plate sit at different heights, covering open melts, toasted sandwiches and thicker items. This helps avoid squashed fillings, which is a common complaint with fixed-hinge presses. Storage is thoughtful: a clip locks the plates together, a rear foot lets the unit stand upright, and the cord wraps into the base. One reviewer gives the smooth toasting surface as about 7-3/4 by 11-1/4 inches, so it takes two sandwiches of ordinary size.
Region matters. Breville’s Canadian page for the base model says it has been discontinued and lists 220 to 240 V, so confirm availability and voltage where you live. The US page shows the BSG520XL at 110 to 120 V.
Hamilton Beach 25410 and the older 25462Z
Hamilton Beach describes the older 25462Z with nonstick grids of 8 by 10 inches and a floating hinge that adjusts to the thickness of the sandwich; the maker’s page for it now says it is no longer available, so it is covered here mainly for buyers who come across remaining stock. A locking lid holds the press upright for storage. On the 25462Z, the lid can also lock above the food for open-face cooking, and the maker recommends preheating for six minutes. Its listed dimensions are about 4.53 in. high, 12.6 in. wide and 12.3 in. deep, and it fits two to three sandwiches at a time.
The 25410 is described as a panini press and indoor grill with a 95 sq in. nonstick surface and a dishwasher-safe drip tray that collects fat. That feature is helpful when you grill burgers or sausages; with a plain sandwich press, grease runs onto the counter. The 25410 listing also mentions PFAS-free grids, but retailer pages and maker pages can differ, so confirm on the product page for the exact model.
Compared with the Breville, the Hamilton Beach models are bigger by plate area and handle more sandwiches at once. They do not offer four preset heights, relying instead on a floating lid. For quick lunches for a family, that is often enough.
What about the Cuisinart Griddler?
Cuisinart’s 5-in-1 Griddler is widely listed. It has removable, reversible plates described as 11 by 9 inches, a floating cover, dishwasher-safe plates and a drip tray, and a wide temperature range. However, one maker page carries a “Discontinued” label and there are inconsistent weight and wattage figures across retailers, so it is not included in the picks. If you find a current Cuisinart contact grill, treat it as a candidate and check the manual, but this guide only names models confirmed on current pages.
Fit, size and care notes
- Counter and cabinet: panini presses are wide when open. Upright storage helps; check the height when stored.
- Cleaning: let the plates cool, then wipe with a damp cloth or soft sponge. Do not use metal utensils on nonstick surfaces. Only wash parts in the dishwasher if the manual says they are dishwasher-safe, such as the drip tray on the 25410.
- Preheating: follow the manual’s preheat time. The 25462Z maker suggests six minutes.
- Bread choice: sturdy bread such as ciabatta or sourdough holds up better than very soft sandwich bread.
Safety
The plates and lid get very hot. Keep children away, use the handle and heat-safe tools, and never immerse the unit in water. Place it on a stable heat-resistant surface with space around it. Unplug when finished and let it cool before storing. Cook meat and poultry fillings fully, using a food thermometer, and follow the manufacturer’s manual for any limits on what you cook.
Getting the best sandwich
Preheat until the indicator light signals the plates are ready. Butter or oil the outside of the bread lightly, since the plates have a nonstick surface and need very little fat. Layer the filling so that moist ingredients such as tomato sit between cheese or meat, which keeps the bread from going soggy. Cut thick fillings thinner so they warm through before the bread over-browns. Lower the lid gently and let the weight of the lid do the work instead of pressing down hard, which squeezes out the filling.
The same press can do more than sandwiches: quesadillas, flatbreads, grilled vegetables, and sliced halloumi or similar cheeses all work on contact plates. Where a model includes a drip tray, it helps with fatty foods. Wipe the plates while they are still warm, not hot, since dried-on cheese is harder to remove. Do not use sharp metal tools that can scratch the coating, and let the unit cool fully before storing it upright.
Pick X if…
| Pick this | If you… |
|---|---|
| Breville BSG520XL | want adjustable plate height and a compact two-sandwich press |
| Hamilton Beach 25462Z (if you find it in stock) | want a simple, roomy press with a floating lid at the lower end of the cap |
| Hamilton Beach 25410 | also want to grill burgers or vegetables and want a drip tray |
| A contact grill or griddle with removable plates | want pancakes, eggs and sandwiches from one machine, and can confirm a current model |
Alternatives
- Stovetop grill pan with a weight: a cast-iron pan plus a heavy lid or second pan makes a pressed sandwich with no extra appliance.
- Sandwich toaster: a sealed-edge toaster makes pocket-style toasties, a different result from panini.
- Air fryer or toaster oven: good for open-faced melts, though they do not press the sandwich.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need a panini press with adjustable height?
It helps with thick fillings or bread. Breville lists four height settings. Hamilton Beach uses a floating lid, which adjusts to sandwich thickness without fixed steps. Either works for ordinary sandwiches.
Can I use a panini press as a grill?
Some can. Hamilton Beach describes the 25410 as a press and indoor grill with a drip tray. Cook meats to a safe internal temperature and follow the manual for what the plates can handle.
How do I stop fillings squeezing out?
Use less filling than you think, choose sturdy bread, and use the height setting or the floating lid so the press does not crush the sandwich. Warm the press fully before cooking.
Are the plates dishwasher-safe?
It depends on the model. The Hamilton Beach 25410 drip tray is listed as dishwasher-safe, but the plates on other models may not be. Check the manual and hand-wash if in doubt.
Is the Breville Panini Duo still sold?
Listings differ. Breville’s Canadian page for the base model states it is discontinued, and some retailers show the BSG520XL as unavailable new. Availability varies by region, so confirm with the seller before relying on it.
How long does a panini take?
It varies with the filling and bread. Preheat first, then cook until the bread is golden and the filling is hot. The manual for your model gives the best guidance.
Related guides



